In the 1990s and 2000s, Maccabi Bnei Reineh played in Liga Gimel and didn't achieve significant achievements. In 2008 the club was folded. In 2016, the club refounded by a local businessman named Saeed Basul, and at the end of the 2016–17 season, the team finished in first place in Liga Gimel Jezreel, and promoted to Liga Bet.

At 2019–20 Israel State Cup qualified to the round of 16, there loss 1–3 to Beitar Jerusalem. At the end of the season promoted to Liga Alef. On 23 September 2020, the club IFA's tribunal ruled, Reineh will play in the next season in Liga Alef, after the previous season stopped due to the COVID-19 epidemic.^[1]

On 6 May 2022 the club promoted to the Israeli Premier League at the first time in the history of the team after 1–0 win against Hapoel Umm al-Fahm.^[2] In doing so, the team completed three consecutive league promotions in three seasons.

On 3 October 2022 the club achieved his first win in the Israeli Premier League after the 3-2 win against Beitar Jerusalem. In this season, it was the only club who neither lost nor conceded a goal from the champions Maccabi Haifa.

Until 2021, Reineh played in the Municipal Stadium in Reineh. After the club promoted to Liga Leumit moved to Green Stadium, Nof HaGalil because the Municipal Stadium wasn't approved to host matches in Liga Leumit. The stadium still used by the club for his home matches in the Israeli Premier League.

As to 5 February, 2024

• Liga Leumit
  • Champions (1): 2021–22

As of 7 September 2022

• Maccabi Bnei Reineh Israel Football Association (in Hebrew)